Justice Taiwo Calls for Clear, Concise Court Judgments to Avoid Confusion

Retired Federal High Court Judge, Justice Taiwo Taiwo, has called for more concise and straightforward court judgments to prevent public confusion and misinterpretation, particularly in today’s politically charged atmosphere. Speaking on Tuesday to Newsmen, organized by the newspaper’s editorial board, the former Chairman of the Nigerian Bar Association, Ikeja branch, discussed the implications of poorly implemented criminal justice and human rights in Nigeria.

Addressing concerns over confusing court rulings, Justice Taiwo noted that lengthy and complex judgments often lead to misunderstandings, with legal professionals sometimes adding to the confusion. He emphasized that judgments should be as brief and clear as possible to avoid misinterpretation, which he attributed to those analyzing the rulings rather than the judgments themselves.

“The problem of confusing judgments is bias. And when I say bias, who stands to gain and who stands to lose?” he questioned, urging judges to keep their rulings succinct and straightforward.

Justice Taiwo also criticized lawyers for complicating cases with overly technical arguments, which make judicial decisions harder for the public to comprehend. He further addressed the issue of bail conditions, arguing that some judges impose unnecessarily harsh requirements “just to flex their muscle.”

The retired judge also condemned human rights violations by security agencies, focusing on searches without warrants and poor investigative practices. He pointed out that law enforcement officers often manipulate the law to justify entering properties without proper legal authorization.

“What baffles me is that some policemen try to manipulate the law to suggest they can enter any property without a warrant, duly applied for, granted, and signed by a judicial officer or justice of the peace,” he said.

In addition, Justice Taiwo criticized the quality of criminal investigations in Nigeria, stressing that thorough examinations of cases should take place before any arrests are made. He cited the prosecution of convicted fraudster Ramon Olorunwa Abbas, a.k.a. “Ray Hushpuppi,” in the U.S. as an example of proper investigative procedures, saying, “The way cases are investigated in Nigeria is tasteless. You have to prove your case beyond a reasonable doubt, not with doubt.”